CRUD Challenge: Too Many Winners
Sep. 27th, 2025 08:11 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
skjamToo Many Winners (1947) dir. William Beaudine
Private eye Michael Shayne (Hugh Beaumont) and his secretary Phyllis Hamilton (Trudy Marshall) have been invited for a duck hunting vacation with one of her relatives. Phyllis is looking forward to this, so is irritated when Gil Madden (Ben Welden) enters, looking like a client. She quickly informs him the office is closed, only for Mr. Madden to say that he'd planned to offer $2000 for Mike not to take a case. Oops! Then Michael gets a call from Mayme Martin (Claire Carlton), a vampish blackmailer offering a hot tip. Naturally, he's off to investigate, promising he'll be right back.
The meeting is inconclusive, as Mayme wants cash up front, and the hints she's giving are for a case Shayne isn't involved with. A thousand dollars is a lot of money for information that might be useless. Outside the apartment building, Mike is abducted by two thugs who want to know what he learned from Mayme, and don't believe him when he truthfully admits he didn't learn anything. They beat him up and toss the detective into the City Dump.
When Shayne finally makes it back to the office a few hours later, the rightfully steamed Phyllis has left on her own, leaving a message about a persistent caller. This turns out to be the owner of the Santa Rosita racetrack, who needs a private eye, and asks him to meet with track manager John Hardeman (Grandon Rhodes) in the Santa Rosita Hotel. Now that he's on the case, Mike asks reporter pal Tim Rourke (Charles Mitchell) to visit Mayme and pay her for the information.
Tim arrives just in time to meet police detective Peter Rafferty (Ralph Dunn) who's investigating Mayme's murder. Tim's presence and peanut shells in an ashtray leads Rafferty to suspect his old enemy Michael Shayne is mixed up in this somehow.
At Santa Rosita, Mike meets with Hardeman and finds out what the case is about. The racetrack has had too many winning tickets recently, consistently more than the number they actually sold. Therefore, someone must be counterfeiting betting slips wholesale--but how? The local police resent Shayne being called in, but they haven't been able to figure the case out, and the track's been losing enough money to not be profitable.
Can Michael Shayne crack the case and win back Phyllis, and how many people will need to die to do this?
This is the last of the Hugh Beaumont Shayne movies (though not the last I will review), and the cast switches up a bit again. The dialogue is still snappy, and the comedy bits hit often. Special callout to George Meader as put-upon hotel clerk Clarence.
This version of Phyllis has a quicker temper than her predecessors, and Mike treats her pretty badly. Because the movie is meant as light-hearted, no one seems very broken up about the multiple corpses, with one exception who's given a sympathetic family so Shayne tries not to make things worse for them.
This is a middle of the road low-budget series film, and perhaps it's best that the studio pulled the plug at this point before the movies really declined. It's short, so I'd recommend it as a double feature with a more gritty mystery. Recommended for lighter mystery fans.
Private eye Michael Shayne (Hugh Beaumont) and his secretary Phyllis Hamilton (Trudy Marshall) have been invited for a duck hunting vacation with one of her relatives. Phyllis is looking forward to this, so is irritated when Gil Madden (Ben Welden) enters, looking like a client. She quickly informs him the office is closed, only for Mr. Madden to say that he'd planned to offer $2000 for Mike not to take a case. Oops! Then Michael gets a call from Mayme Martin (Claire Carlton), a vampish blackmailer offering a hot tip. Naturally, he's off to investigate, promising he'll be right back.
The meeting is inconclusive, as Mayme wants cash up front, and the hints she's giving are for a case Shayne isn't involved with. A thousand dollars is a lot of money for information that might be useless. Outside the apartment building, Mike is abducted by two thugs who want to know what he learned from Mayme, and don't believe him when he truthfully admits he didn't learn anything. They beat him up and toss the detective into the City Dump.
When Shayne finally makes it back to the office a few hours later, the rightfully steamed Phyllis has left on her own, leaving a message about a persistent caller. This turns out to be the owner of the Santa Rosita racetrack, who needs a private eye, and asks him to meet with track manager John Hardeman (Grandon Rhodes) in the Santa Rosita Hotel. Now that he's on the case, Mike asks reporter pal Tim Rourke (Charles Mitchell) to visit Mayme and pay her for the information.
Tim arrives just in time to meet police detective Peter Rafferty (Ralph Dunn) who's investigating Mayme's murder. Tim's presence and peanut shells in an ashtray leads Rafferty to suspect his old enemy Michael Shayne is mixed up in this somehow.
At Santa Rosita, Mike meets with Hardeman and finds out what the case is about. The racetrack has had too many winning tickets recently, consistently more than the number they actually sold. Therefore, someone must be counterfeiting betting slips wholesale--but how? The local police resent Shayne being called in, but they haven't been able to figure the case out, and the track's been losing enough money to not be profitable.
Can Michael Shayne crack the case and win back Phyllis, and how many people will need to die to do this?
This is the last of the Hugh Beaumont Shayne movies (though not the last I will review), and the cast switches up a bit again. The dialogue is still snappy, and the comedy bits hit often. Special callout to George Meader as put-upon hotel clerk Clarence.
This version of Phyllis has a quicker temper than her predecessors, and Mike treats her pretty badly. Because the movie is meant as light-hearted, no one seems very broken up about the multiple corpses, with one exception who's given a sympathetic family so Shayne tries not to make things worse for them.
This is a middle of the road low-budget series film, and perhaps it's best that the studio pulled the plug at this point before the movies really declined. It's short, so I'd recommend it as a double feature with a more gritty mystery. Recommended for lighter mystery fans.
