CRUD Challenge: Starship Troopers (1997)
Sep. 22nd, 2025 02:27 pmStarship Troopers (1997) dir. Paul Verhoeven
John D. "Johnny" Rico (Casper Van Dien) is a jumpball star at his local high school in Buenos Aires in the 22nd Century. But he has decided he doesn't want to go professional, and he's having second thoughts about simply working for his wealthy father's (Christopher Curry) company. Instead, he's thinking of going into government service, which guarantees citizenship, the right to vote. He's been influenced in this by his civics teacher, Jean Raszcak (Michael Ironside) who flatly states that most civilians can't cut it in government service, and his girlfriend Carmen Ibanez (Denise Richards), who is signing up herself.
Despite his parents' strong objections, Johnny signs up right out of high school, as do Carmen, Dizzy Flores (Dana Meyer) who is a fellow jumpball player and attracted to Johnny, and Carl Jenkins (Neil Patrick Harris), a "sensitive" with some psychic abilities. Carmen gets a prestigious flight academy posting, Carl is sent off to military research, while Johnny and Dizzy, not exactly being mental powerhouses, have to "settle" for the Mobile Infantry, the grunts of the future military.
At boot camp, Johnny meets tough but fair drill instructor Sergeant Zim (Clancy Brown), new best friend Ace Levy (Jake Busey), and a number of other recruits. Johnny's skillset and personality give him potential as a soldier, and he's soon a temporary squad leader. Then a fatal training mistake shatters Johnny's confidence. He's about to quit when the conflict with an alien species called the Bugs goes hot with the destruction of Buenos Aires. A war's on now, and Johnny is going to do his part!
Would you like to know more?
This sci-fi action movie is loosely based on Robert A. Heinlein's novel of the same name. And by "loosely", I mean that the director read the first couple of chapters, bounced hard, asked the scriptwriter to summarize the plot, then decided to make a satire of what he thought the book's themes were, completely missing the actual social commentary contained therein.
Which is not to say it isn't a great movie. You just have to catch that it's an in-universe propaganda film made by a fascist regime to sell an ill-thought-out war to its populace. There are plenty of hints. The Buenos Aires characters might have Hispanic names, but are conspicuously white-looking and don't show any signs of Hispanic culture. Buenos Aires might be a city from the little we see of it, but the high school sure looks feels like a small-town school. Once we get into the military portion, there's a lot of echoes of fascist symbology. The tactics are laughable, and some of the propaganda blurbs are outright silly.
And of course, to make a good satire, it also has to work as an actual example of the genre. A likeable hero, relatable struggles, awesome action and reasonably plausible plot twists.
Instead of the book's single narrative following just Johnny, we cut to Carmen's story every so often, making her an actual character in the story. This also allows the filmmakers to introduce romance subplotting that was almost completely ignored in the book.
The special effects are top-notch for the time, and haven't aged badly at all.
Will we ever see a reasonably faithful adaptation of the book? Probably not. It's very much a reaction to American (and to a lesser extent global) conditions of the 1950s and so would need updating to deal with current cultural touchstones. (For example, a Filipino as the protagonist would be seen by conservatives as "woke" rather than the mind-blowing reveal it was when the book was first published.)
In the meantime, we have this twisted adaptation to enjoy.
Content note: Lots of military violence, often gory and/or lethal. Quite a bit of mutilation and severed limbs. Torture by whipping. A cow dies with minimal censoring. Extramarital sex just off-camera. Male and female nudity, including the infamous mixed shower scene. People with bug phobias might want to skip this altogether. Vomiting. Some rough language. This is an R-rated movie and fully earns that.
People who prefer their science fiction serious should read the book instead. Also, if you see the movie I recommend reading the book so see what Heinlein was actually talking about. Still, this is a good movie, and recommended to people who understand where the director is coming from.
John D. "Johnny" Rico (Casper Van Dien) is a jumpball star at his local high school in Buenos Aires in the 22nd Century. But he has decided he doesn't want to go professional, and he's having second thoughts about simply working for his wealthy father's (Christopher Curry) company. Instead, he's thinking of going into government service, which guarantees citizenship, the right to vote. He's been influenced in this by his civics teacher, Jean Raszcak (Michael Ironside) who flatly states that most civilians can't cut it in government service, and his girlfriend Carmen Ibanez (Denise Richards), who is signing up herself.
Despite his parents' strong objections, Johnny signs up right out of high school, as do Carmen, Dizzy Flores (Dana Meyer) who is a fellow jumpball player and attracted to Johnny, and Carl Jenkins (Neil Patrick Harris), a "sensitive" with some psychic abilities. Carmen gets a prestigious flight academy posting, Carl is sent off to military research, while Johnny and Dizzy, not exactly being mental powerhouses, have to "settle" for the Mobile Infantry, the grunts of the future military.
At boot camp, Johnny meets tough but fair drill instructor Sergeant Zim (Clancy Brown), new best friend Ace Levy (Jake Busey), and a number of other recruits. Johnny's skillset and personality give him potential as a soldier, and he's soon a temporary squad leader. Then a fatal training mistake shatters Johnny's confidence. He's about to quit when the conflict with an alien species called the Bugs goes hot with the destruction of Buenos Aires. A war's on now, and Johnny is going to do his part!
Would you like to know more?
This sci-fi action movie is loosely based on Robert A. Heinlein's novel of the same name. And by "loosely", I mean that the director read the first couple of chapters, bounced hard, asked the scriptwriter to summarize the plot, then decided to make a satire of what he thought the book's themes were, completely missing the actual social commentary contained therein.
Which is not to say it isn't a great movie. You just have to catch that it's an in-universe propaganda film made by a fascist regime to sell an ill-thought-out war to its populace. There are plenty of hints. The Buenos Aires characters might have Hispanic names, but are conspicuously white-looking and don't show any signs of Hispanic culture. Buenos Aires might be a city from the little we see of it, but the high school sure looks feels like a small-town school. Once we get into the military portion, there's a lot of echoes of fascist symbology. The tactics are laughable, and some of the propaganda blurbs are outright silly.
And of course, to make a good satire, it also has to work as an actual example of the genre. A likeable hero, relatable struggles, awesome action and reasonably plausible plot twists.
Instead of the book's single narrative following just Johnny, we cut to Carmen's story every so often, making her an actual character in the story. This also allows the filmmakers to introduce romance subplotting that was almost completely ignored in the book.
The special effects are top-notch for the time, and haven't aged badly at all.
Will we ever see a reasonably faithful adaptation of the book? Probably not. It's very much a reaction to American (and to a lesser extent global) conditions of the 1950s and so would need updating to deal with current cultural touchstones. (For example, a Filipino as the protagonist would be seen by conservatives as "woke" rather than the mind-blowing reveal it was when the book was first published.)
In the meantime, we have this twisted adaptation to enjoy.
Content note: Lots of military violence, often gory and/or lethal. Quite a bit of mutilation and severed limbs. Torture by whipping. A cow dies with minimal censoring. Extramarital sex just off-camera. Male and female nudity, including the infamous mixed shower scene. People with bug phobias might want to skip this altogether. Vomiting. Some rough language. This is an R-rated movie and fully earns that.
People who prefer their science fiction serious should read the book instead. Also, if you see the movie I recommend reading the book so see what Heinlein was actually talking about. Still, this is a good movie, and recommended to people who understand where the director is coming from.