CRUD Challenge: Choices (1981)
Sep. 11th, 2025 08:28 amChoices (1981) dir. Silvio Narizzano
John Carluccio (Paul Carafotes) has a pretty good life. Yes, he's got severe hearing loss due to a childhood accident, but with the help of a hearing aid, he's able to function in hearing society just fine. He's first violin in his high school orchestra (been playing since age 3 due to his grandfather (George Barrows) urging it on him, Gramps also being the orchestra director. John's the star running back on the football team, which actually has a chance of making it into the playoffs this year. And on nights when he doesn't have too much school stuff going on, he plays fiddle in a rockabilly band at the local bar.
Trouble comes when the old school doctor retires and is replaced by Dr. Bowers (Dennis Patrick). While reviewing the school's medical records, Dr. Bowers notices John's hearing loss and decides that he should no longer be allowed to play football. This decision understandably enrages John, as well as his father Gary (Victor French) whose own athletic dreams were crushed by injury, and Coach Rizzo (Val Avery) who's finally got a team with a shot at the championship. Gramps thinks this is okay because it will allow John to devote more time to music. And while most of the football team is supportive of John, Lance (Don Stark), the back-up running back who's been benched most of the season due to John being just so much better, would just as soon have his rival out of the way.
Now, Dr. Bowers means well, and his point isn't that John physically can't play football (which makes the attempts to show Dr. Bowers that he can kind of redundant) but that further injury could make John lose his remaining hearing, and John has never bothered to learn lip reading or sign language, so he's woefully unprepared for total deafness. But Dr. Bowers is bad at explaining himself, especially to teenagers, and comes across as arbitrary and cruel.
When the matter is brought up to the school board, they let the doctor's decision stand so that they can review the evidence and make a decision at their next meeting in two weeks.
While he also loves music, John's identity as a high school student is tied to his stardom as a football player. Banned from the sport, he begins to spiral. He starts hanging out with his hoodlum friend Chris (Stephen Nicols) way more, begins smoking and drinking, and having fights with his family and other friends.
Oh, and sweetheart Corri (Demi Moore) is also there.
This TV movie is allegedly based on a true story, and veers into Afterschool Special territory. It's mostly remembered now for being Demi Moore's first official movie role, and the promotional art features her heavily, though she's got a small supporting role. She does okay in it.
The music is good, both the classical music played by the school orchestra, and the original songs played by the band or just on the soundtrack. There's some effective sound design to show John's hearing loss.
John's downward spiral is perhaps a bit too steep and fast for plausibility, and tends towards the melodramatic, but is excusable to fit it within ninety minutes run time and a bit over two weeks in story time.
The acting ranges from wooden to average; the most interesting job is done by Pat Buttram as "Pops" the folksy bar owner.
Content notes: Some fistfights. Relatively mild ableism. Underage drinking and smoking. Chris' character leans a little too much into stereotypes of "the criminal class." Teenagers should be able to handle it just fine.
It's an okay TV drama of its time and place. Recommended primarily to families with teenagers who can use it to spark discussions. Demi Moore fans will be disappointed, so only for completionists.
John Carluccio (Paul Carafotes) has a pretty good life. Yes, he's got severe hearing loss due to a childhood accident, but with the help of a hearing aid, he's able to function in hearing society just fine. He's first violin in his high school orchestra (been playing since age 3 due to his grandfather (George Barrows) urging it on him, Gramps also being the orchestra director. John's the star running back on the football team, which actually has a chance of making it into the playoffs this year. And on nights when he doesn't have too much school stuff going on, he plays fiddle in a rockabilly band at the local bar.
Trouble comes when the old school doctor retires and is replaced by Dr. Bowers (Dennis Patrick). While reviewing the school's medical records, Dr. Bowers notices John's hearing loss and decides that he should no longer be allowed to play football. This decision understandably enrages John, as well as his father Gary (Victor French) whose own athletic dreams were crushed by injury, and Coach Rizzo (Val Avery) who's finally got a team with a shot at the championship. Gramps thinks this is okay because it will allow John to devote more time to music. And while most of the football team is supportive of John, Lance (Don Stark), the back-up running back who's been benched most of the season due to John being just so much better, would just as soon have his rival out of the way.
Now, Dr. Bowers means well, and his point isn't that John physically can't play football (which makes the attempts to show Dr. Bowers that he can kind of redundant) but that further injury could make John lose his remaining hearing, and John has never bothered to learn lip reading or sign language, so he's woefully unprepared for total deafness. But Dr. Bowers is bad at explaining himself, especially to teenagers, and comes across as arbitrary and cruel.
When the matter is brought up to the school board, they let the doctor's decision stand so that they can review the evidence and make a decision at their next meeting in two weeks.
While he also loves music, John's identity as a high school student is tied to his stardom as a football player. Banned from the sport, he begins to spiral. He starts hanging out with his hoodlum friend Chris (Stephen Nicols) way more, begins smoking and drinking, and having fights with his family and other friends.
Oh, and sweetheart Corri (Demi Moore) is also there.
This TV movie is allegedly based on a true story, and veers into Afterschool Special territory. It's mostly remembered now for being Demi Moore's first official movie role, and the promotional art features her heavily, though she's got a small supporting role. She does okay in it.
The music is good, both the classical music played by the school orchestra, and the original songs played by the band or just on the soundtrack. There's some effective sound design to show John's hearing loss.
John's downward spiral is perhaps a bit too steep and fast for plausibility, and tends towards the melodramatic, but is excusable to fit it within ninety minutes run time and a bit over two weeks in story time.
The acting ranges from wooden to average; the most interesting job is done by Pat Buttram as "Pops" the folksy bar owner.
Content notes: Some fistfights. Relatively mild ableism. Underage drinking and smoking. Chris' character leans a little too much into stereotypes of "the criminal class." Teenagers should be able to handle it just fine.
It's an okay TV drama of its time and place. Recommended primarily to families with teenagers who can use it to spark discussions. Demi Moore fans will be disappointed, so only for completionists.